Farm Table Talk: Masculinity Isn’t the Problem—But Toxicity Is

The conversation around masculinity has been wrecked by extremes. On one side, you have people claiming masculinity itself is toxic, that men need to be softer, weaker, or erased altogether. On the other, you have people clinging to outdated stereotypes of dominance, control, and emotional suppression like their sense of worth depends on it. Neither of these positions fix anything, because masculinity itself is not the issue—it’s toxic masculinity that’s the problem.

Masculinity, in its healthy form, is necessary. It builds, protects, leads, provides. It fosters strength, integrity, and responsibility. But when masculinity turns toxic, it stops being about leadership and starts being about control. It stops being about protection and turns into possession. It stops being about empowerment and becomes suppression.

To make this crystal clear, here’s the difference between healthy masculinity and toxic masculinity.

Healthy masculinity means stepping up without overpowering others. It means being strong not just for yourself, but for the people who depend on you. It means respecting those around you as partners, not inferiors. It looks like:

• Protecting without controlling. Ensuring safety when needed, but never restricting autonomy or choices.
• Encouraging strength in others. Uplifting people, not belittling them for showing vulnerability or emotion.
• Leading by example, not by intimidation. Taking responsibility, guiding with wisdom, not with fear tactics.
• Expressing emotion with integrity. Understanding that vulnerability isn’t weakness, that honesty creates trust and respect.
• Respecting the balance of roles. Recognizing that masculinity and femininity complement each other rather than competing.

Toxic masculinity, on the other hand, is what people are actually referring to when they say “men are the problem”—because toxic masculinity takes everything strong and turns it into something destructive. It looks like:

• Viewing women as servants, not partners. Assuming women exist to cater to male needs rather than recognizing their independence and capabilities.
• Belittling emotions. Calling compassion weakness, shaming men and women alike for expressing vulnerability.
• Gatekeeping strength. Acting like only men can be physically, mentally, or emotionally resilient, dismissing the abilities of women.
• Controlling through intimidation. Using fear and dominance instead of wisdom and respect to hold influence over others.
• Mocking femininity. Degrading nurturing, gentleness, and emotional intelligence as lesser traits instead of recognizing them as strengths.

And here’s where things get real: Toxic masculinity is a shield for avoiding responsibility. It gives men an easy way out, a free pass to dismiss emotional intelligence, deflect accountability, and hide behind outdated power structures instead of stepping up.

Accountability is hard. It means admitting faults, failures, and blind spots. It means being strong enough to face them instead of pretending they don’t exist. But toxic masculinity? It gives men an easy excuse. It says, “You don’t have to grow, change, or take responsibility—just blame women, blame emotions, blame anything but yourself.”

That’s why so many men fight this conversation—because real masculinity requires effort, humility, and self-awareness, and not everyone is willing to do the work.

The irony? Healthy masculinity is far more powerful than toxic masculinity ever could be. Strength rooted in integrity, wisdom, and accountability will always outlast strength based on arrogance and fear.

But hey—evolving requires reflection, and reflection requires breaking through layers of denial. Some people aren’t ready for that.

So let’s stop pretending masculinity itself is the problem. Masculinity is vital. Masculinity is necessary. Masculinity, when done right, makes society better.

But toxic masculinity? It’s nothing but misplaced ego disguised as strength. And it’s time we called it out for what it is.

What do you think? Have you seen toxic masculinity wreck situations that didn’t need to be wrecked? Pull up a chair—let’s talk about why it’s time for men to step up the right way.

---

There’s nothing like the taste of fresh, pasture-raised eggs from a farm that prioritizes quality, nutrition, and ethical care. Our hens produce rich, flavorful eggs, perfect for everything from breakfast to baking. Whether you’re stocking up for your home or looking for a reliable local source, our farm-fresh eggs are a delicious addition to your kitchen. Order yours today!